EU Data Protection
December 19, 2009
* The eYouGuide now speaks 10 languages

The eYouGuide, Europe's first online tool giving consumers practical advice on their "digital rights" under EU law is now available in 10 languages. "The eYouGuide was launched in Strasbourg on 5 May 2009 (see IP/09/702). The guide provides information on a number of issues related to online activities, such as shopping online, networking, uploading and downloading content and making online payments, just to mention a few. It is meant as a tool to improve consumers' awareness and confidence in the digital environment. The website will be updated and extended to more EU languages at the beginning of 2010."

May 13, 2009
* Rand: Review of the European Data Protection Directive

Review of the European Data Protection Directive, by Neil Robinson, Hans Graux, Maarten Botterman, Lorenzo Valeri

  • "The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) asked a multidisciplinary international research team led by RAND Europe with time-lex and GNKS-Consult to review the strengths and weaknesses of the European Data Protection Directive 95/46/EC and propose avenues for improvement. The Directive can be regarded as a unique legal instrument in how it supports the exercise of a right to privacy and rules for personal data protection. Its principles are regarded in many quarters as a gold standard or reference model for personal data protection in Europe and beyond. However, the Directive must remain valid in the face of new challenges, including globalisation, the ongoing march of technological capability and the changing ways that personal data is used. Although the flexibility of the Directive helps it to remain current, its effectiveness is undermined by the complexity of the cultural and national differences across which it must operate."
  • March 24, 2009
    * Database State - a comprehensive map of UK government databases

    Database State, Executive Summary and Full Report - By Ross Anderson, Ian Brown, Terri Dowty, Philip Inglesant, William Heath, Angela Sasse, Foundation for Information Policy Research (March 2009)

  • "In recent years, the Government has built or extended many central databases that hold information on every aspect of our lives, from health and education to welfare, law–enforcement and tax. This ‘Transformational Government’ programme was supposed to make public services better or cheaper, but it has been repeatedly challenged by controversies over effectiveness, privacy, legality and cost. Many question the consequences of giving increasing numbers of civil servants daily access to our personal information. Objections range from cost through efficiency to privacy. The emphasis on data capture, form-filling, mechanical assessment and profiling damages professional responsibility and alienates the citizen from the state. Over two-thirds of the population no longer trust the government with their personal data. This report charts these databases, creating the most comprehensive map so far of what has become Britain’s Database State."
  • October 13, 2008
    * Commission consults on how to put Europe into the lead of the transition to Web 3.0

    News release, September 29, 2008: "Europe could take the lead in the next generation of the Internet. The European Commission today outlined the main steps that Europe has to take to respond to the next wave of the Information Revolution that will intensify in the coming years due to trends such as social networking, the decisive shift to on-line business services, nomadic services based on GPS and mobile TV and the growth of smart tags. The report shows that Europe is well placed to exploit these trends because of its policies to support open and pro-competitive telecom networks as well as privacy and security. A public consultation has been launched today by the Commission on the policy and private sector responses to these opportunities. The Commission report also unveils a new Broadband Performance Index (BPI) that compares national performance on key measures such as broadband speed, price, competition and coverage. Sweden and the Netherlands top this European broadband league, which complements the more traditional broadband penetration index used so far by telecoms regulators."

    September 09, 2008
    * Google Announces Revised User Record Retention Policy

    Official Google Blog: "we're announcing a new logs retention policy: we'll anonymize IP addresses on our server logs after 9 months. We're significantly shortening our previous 18-month retention policy to address regulatory concerns and to take another step to improve privacy for our users."

  • Related: Google Response to the [EU] Article 29 Working Party Opinion On Data Protection Issues Related to Search Engines
  • June 03, 2008
    * EU - Report on the Future of European Home Affairs Policy

    Freedom, Security, Privacy – European Home Affairs in an open world - Report of the Informal High Level Advisory Group on the Future of European Home Affairs Policy ("The Future Group"), June 2008

    April 26, 2008
    * International Privacy Officials Recommend Social Networking Privacy Safeguards

    EPIC: "The International Working Group On Data Protection in Telecommunications has released a report and guidance (pdf) on privacy in social networking services. The report identifies risks to privacy and security, and provides guidance to regulators, service operators and users to counter these risks. Risks include the large amount of data collection; the misuse of profile data by third parties; insecure infrastructure and application programming interfaces. Regulators should ensure openness, and oblige data breach notification. Providers must be transparent; live up to promises made to users; and use privacy friendly defaults. Privacy and consumer groups are also
    recommended to raise the awareness of regulators, providers and the general public."

  • Report and Guidance on Privacy in Social Network Services - ”Rome Memorandum” - 43rd meeting, 3-4 March 2008, Rome (Italy)

  • A brochure containing all documents adopted by the International Working Group until 2006 (in German and English) is available for download here.
  • April 18, 2008
    * ACLU letter to President of the EU's Article 29 Working Group

    Barry Steinhart, director of the ACLU Technology & Liberty Project: April 16, 2008 Letter from the ACLU to the President of the European Union's Article 29 Working Group urging investigation of NSA spying.

  • "We would like to take this opportunity to raise with you and your colleagues our concerns regarding new extrajudicial surveillance of European and other foreigners’ activities that is being conducted by the United States on the basis of traffic data and content communications. We believe that this surveillance contravenes the requirements for the protection of the private life under article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights and accordingly the EU Directive 1995 on the processing of personal information and the 2002 E.Privacy Directive. Telecommunications service providers across Europe and around the world that provide communications services to Europeans are likely to be in breach of these laws. And the communications privacy of European citizens and those persons, including Americans, with whom they communicate, is in significant jeopardy."
    Because much of the world's communications travel through switching points in the United States, Internet transactions and email between Europeans is increasingly sent through servers in the U.S. This greatly aids the NSA in its surveillance. (This amazing map on Wired News pretty much conveys the situation in a single glance.)"
  • April 13, 2008
    * Legally eHealth: Putting eHealth in its European Legal Context

    Legally eHealth: Putting eHealth in its European Legal Context. Legal and regulatory aspects of eHealth Study report March 2008.

  • "The Legally eHealth Report...seeks to examine some keys of the legal questions raised by the adoption of eHealth tools in healthcare. It looks at how EU legislation on data protection, product and services liability, and trade and competition law applies. In considering the law of privacy, the report examines the European Directives on Data Protection Directive, Privacy in Electronic Communications, as well as the European Convention of Human Rights against the backdrop of a number of scenarios exploring data transfer for the purposes of better care provision both across European and international borders, as well as for commercial purposes."
  • April 07, 2008
    * European Privacy Officials: Privacy Rules Apply to Search Engines

    EPIC: "European privacy officials have established "a clear set of responsibilities" on search engine companies regarding their handling of user data. The opinion, issued by the Article 29 Working Group, states that the European Union Data Protection Directive requires search engines to "delete or irreversibly anonymise personal data once they no longer serve the specified and legitimate purpose" for which they were collected. This requirement has particular significance for search engines, because European privacy rules classify Internet Protocol (IP) addresses as "personal data." The opinion further holds that European privacy laws generally apply to search engines "even when their headquarters are outside [Europe]," and requires that search engines must delete personal data within six months of collection. Earlier this year, EPIC urged the European Parliament to protect the privacy of search histories. For more information, see EPIC's Search Engine Privacy page."

    April 01, 2008
    * Cybercrime Legislation: EU Country Profiles

    Cybercrime Legislation - Country profiles: "These profiles have been prepared within the framework of the Council of Europe’s Project on Cybercrime in view of sharing information on cybercrime legislation and assessing the current state of implementation of the Convention on Cybercrime under national legislation. They do not necessarily reflect official positions of the countries covered or of the Council of Europe."

  • Octopus Interface 2008 - Cooperation against Cybercrime,
    Tuesday 1 - Wednesday 2 April 2008, Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France. "The 2008 Conference will focus on the cooperation between service providers and law enforcement, the state of cybercrime legislation and the effectiveness of international cooperation. In the face of the increasing vulnerability of societies to the threat of cybercrime the Conference provides a platform for enhancing cooperation among key stakeholders from around the world."
  • March 11, 2008
    * Google Finalizes Acquisition of DoubleClick

    Follow up to previous postings on the Google-DoubleClick merger, this announcement today from Eric Schmidt, Google Chairman and CEO: "I'm pleased to share the news that we completed our acquisition of DoubleClick today. Although it's been nearly a year since we announced our intention to acquire DoubleClick last April, we are no less excited today about the benefits that the combination of our two companies will bring to the online advertising market."

  • Related news today: "The European Commission has cleared under the EU Merger Regulation the proposed acquisition of the online advertising technology company DoubleClick by Google, both of the US. The Commission’s in-depth investigation, opened in November 2007 (see IP/07/1688), concluded that the transaction would be unlikely to have harmful effects on consumers, either in ad serving or in intermediation in online advertising markets. The Commission has therefore concluded that the transaction would not significantly impede effective competition within the European Economic Area (EEA) or a significant part of it."
  • March 01, 2008
    * EU Safer Internet Plus Programme

    "The Safer Internet plus programme aims to promote safer use of the Internet and new online technologies, particularly for children, and to fight against illegal content and content unwanted by the end-user, as part of a coherent approach by the European Union."

  • Make the internet a safer place, February 2008: While the international context is complex, the EU has set certain standards across Europe, clarifying many legal issues. The internet related issues, however, cannot be tackled by legal measures alone, and are generally greater than parents realise. With broadband access growing – both via PCs and ‘third generation’ (3G) mobile phones – and as the internet becomes an increasingly important part of children’s lives, these figures are not likely to become less disturbing without
    concerted action."
  • February 10, 2008
    * One person in eight in the EU27 avoids e-shopping because of security concerns

    Press release: "In connection with the 5th Safer Internet Day1 on 12 February 2008, Eurostat, the Statistical Office of the European Communities, presents a selection of statistics concerning internet activities, security concerns and virus attacks. The Safer Internet Day is part of a global drive to promote a safer Internet for all users, in particular younger people, and is organised by Insafe, a European internet safety network co-funded by the European Commission...In the EU27 in 2007, nearly a quarter of internet users had had a computer virus in the preceding 12 months, which resulted in a loss of information or time. Virus attacks were most frequent in Lithuania (41% of users), Slovenia (35%) and Malta (34%) and least common in the Czech Republic (7%), Estonia (15%) and Sweden (16%)."

    January 27, 2008
    * EU Data Protection Day, January 28, 2008

    "The aim of the Data Protection Day is to give European citizens the chance to understand what personal data is collected and processed about them and why, and what their rights are with respect to this processing. They should also be made aware of the risks inherent and associated with the illegal mishandling and unfair processing of their personal data. The objective of the Data Protection Day is therefore to inform and educate the public at large as to their day-to-day rights, but it may also provide data protection professionals with the opportunity of meeting data subjects."

    October 04, 2007
    * European Security Research Agenda: European Commission Working documents

    European Security Research Agenda: European Commission Working documents: Public-Private Dialogue in Security Research and Innovation: Summary of the Impact Assessment (SEC (2007); Public-Private Dialogue in Security Research and Innovation: Impact Assessment (SEC (2007)

  • See also Security research to better combat terrorism

  • September 15, 2007
    * Google Privacy Chief Calls for International Data Protection Standards

    Heise Online: "The world's number one search engine Google is calling for international standards for data protection. "Three quarters of the countries in the world have no privacy regimes at all", Peter Fleischer, Google's Privacy Chief, explained at a conference organized by UNESCO, the UN's Education, Science, and Culture Organization, on the topic of "Internet Ethics". What's worse, Fleischer pointed out that even the countries in Europe and the OECD (Organization for Economic Collaboration and Development) that do have such laws wrote them up back when the Internet did not have the impact it currently does."

    July 26, 2007
    * New Agreement With EU For Passenger Name Record Data Sharing

    Press release: "Secretary Michael Chertoff made the following statement: "I am pleased to have signed an important agreement with the European Union today that will allow the Department of Homeland Security to continue using Passenger Name Record (PNR) data as an essential screening tool for detecting potentially dangerous transatlantic travelers."

  • 2007 PNR Agreement - U.S. version (PDF, 7 pages)

  • Letter from the Council of the European Union to the United States (PDF, 3 pages)

  • Letter from the United States to the Council of the European Union (PDF, 5 pages
  • )

    July 06, 2007
    * European Commission Opens Inquiry into Google/DoubleClick Merger

    Follow up to the Google DoubleClick Merger In the News, from EPIC: The European Commission Directorate on Competition will review Google's $3.1 billion merger with internet advertising company DoubleClick. The news comes a few days after European consumer group BEUC sent a letter (pdf) urging Commission to investigate the merger. The Article 29 Data Protection Working Party recently expanded (pdf) an investigation of Google's data retention policies to include the policies of all search engines. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission also is reviewing the merger."

    June 13, 2007
    * Google Agrees to Cut Data Retention Time in Response to EU Privacy Laws

    EPIC reports: "Google will cut the period that it retains user data from a maximum of 24 months to a maximum of 18 months, the company said in a letter (pdf) to the Article 29 Data Protection Working Party. Last month, the Working Party began to investigate (pdf) Google's privacy practices and asked whether the company has "fulfilled all the necessary requirements" to abide by EU privacy rules. In its letter, Google did not adequately explain why it needed to retain user data for 18 or 24 months, except to vaguely say that the data would help Google build new services, possibly help prevent fraud and abuse, and that the U.S. and EU member states might impose a 24-month retention requirement."

  • See also this June 10, 2007 posting, Privacy Ranking Report of Internet Service Companies and this Official Google Blog posting by Peter Fleischer, Global Privacy Counsel, on the EU data rention issue.
  • June 05, 2007
    * EU/US Passenger Name Record (PNR) Agreement

    European Union Committee, Home Affairs (Sub-Committee F), The EU/US Passenger Name Record (PNR) Agreement, HL Paper 108 is published today Tuesday 5th June, 2007 (139 pages, PDF). [see also HTML version (browsable)]

  • Press release: The House of Lords EU Committee raises concerns over passenger name record agreement with the US
  • April 20, 2007
    * EU Report on Digital Preservation, Orphan Works and Out-of-Print Works

    "The Report on Digital Preservation, Orphan Works and Out-of-Print Works, Selected Implementation Issues is an advisory report on copyright issues to the European Commission, presented on 19 April by the EU's High Level Expert Group on Digital Libraries - which includes, inter alia, stakeholders from the British Library, the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, the Federation of European Publishers and Google."

  • "The EU's High Level Expert Group on Digital Libraries - which includes, inter alia, stakeholders from the British Library, the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, the Federation of European Publishers and Google - will present this afternoon an advisory report on copyright issues to the European Commission. In addition, the group will discuss today how to ensure more open access to scientific research and how to improve public-private cooperation. The work of the High Level Group is part of the European Commission's efforts to make Europe's rich cultural and scientific heritage available online. For this purpose, the group advises the Commission on issues regarding digitisation, online accessibility and digital preservation of cultural material."

  • Report on Digital Preservation, Orphan Works and Out-of-Print Works, Selected Implementation Issues

  • Annex: Model agreement for a licence on digitisation of out of print works
  • March 14, 2007
    * Google Announces Change in Privacy Policy on Storage of Server Logs

    Taking steps to further improve our privacy practices: Posted by Peter Fleischer, Privacy Counsel-Europe, and Nicole Wong, Deputy General Counsel: "When you search on Google, we collect information about your search, such as the query itself, IP addresses and cookie details. Previously, we kept this data for as long as it was useful. Today we're pleased to report a change in our privacy policy: Unless we're legally required to retain log data for longer, we will anonymize our server logs after a limited period of time. When we implement this policy change in the coming months, we will continue to keep server log data (so that we can improve Google's services and protect them from security and other abuses)—but will make this data much more anonymous, so that it can no longer be identified with individual users, after 18-24 months...Just as we continuously work to improve our products, we also work toward having the best privacy practices for our users. This includes designing privacy protections into our products (like Google Talk's “off the record” feature or Google Desktop’s “pause” and “lock search” controls). This also means providing clear, easy to understand privacy policies that help you make informed decisions about using our services. After talking with leading privacy stakeholders in Europe and the U.S., we're pleased to be taking this important step toward protecting your privacy. By anonymizing our server logs after 18-24 months, we think we’re striking the right balance between two goals: continuing to improve Google’s services for you, while providing more transparency and certainty about our retention practices. In the future, it's possible that data retention laws will obligate us to retain logs for longer periods. Of course, you can always choose to have us retain this data for more personalized services like Search History. But that's up to you. Our engineers are already busy working out the technical details, and we hope to implement this new data policy over the coming months (and within a year's time). We’ll communicate more as we work out these details, but for now, we wanted you to know that we’re working on this additional step to strengthen your privacy. If you want to know more, read the log retention FAQ (PDF)."

  • Danny Sullivan provides a step by step explanation of the impact of this announcement, in his posting, Google Anonymizing Search Records To Protect Privacy.

  • January 23, 2007
    * EU eGovernment Action Plan Roadmaps

    "The European Commission in co-operation with the Member States has finalised the roadmaps for the action plans on Pan-European Electronic Identity Management, Electronic Procurement and Inclusive eGovernment. In view of the continuous and fast evolution in these areas, we shall conduct an annual revision of these roadmaps.

  • Electronic Identity Management roadmap table and paper

  • Electronic Procurement roadmap

  • Inclusive eGovernment roadmap. See also the reports 'Options for administrative actions towards the i2010 inclusive eGovernment goal' and 'Analysis of European target groups related to inclusive eGovernment'

  • You can see also the plan of activities 2007-2010 for eGovernment Efficiency and Effectiveness
  • November 29, 2006
    * New EU Communication on Spam

    Press release: "The Commission today called on all regulatory authorities and stakeholders in Europe to step up the fight against spam, spyware and malicious software. Despite existing EU legislation to outlaw spam in Europe, Europe continues to suffer from illegal online activities from inside the EU and from third countries, the Commission underlines in a new Communication. The Communication stresses that although internet safety is on the political agenda for some time, national authorities should step up their actions to prosecute illegal online activities."

  • Related press release: "Sophos, a world leader in IT security, has published its latest report on the top twelve spam relaying countries over the third quarter of 2006. Sophos experts believe that a possible reason for America's increasing lead in relayed spam when compared to its closest rival, China, is the emergence of over 300 strains of the mass-spammed Stratio worm."
  • November 26, 2006
    * Processing of Personal Data By SWIFTand EU Data Protection Opinion

    Follow-up to previous postings on the SWIFT online financial cooperative network, this November 23, 2006 corporate press release:

  • "SWIFT strongly objects to WP 29's opinion [Opinion 10/2006 on the processing of personal data by the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT), 11/26/2006 WP 128] about the communication of personal data to the US Treasury (UST). SWIFT acted responsibly within applicable laws by complying with mandatory UST subpoenas for limited sets of data in the US for the exclusive purpose of terrorism investigations. It obtained from the UST extraordinary protections and control mechanisms that met both its obligations to protect the confidentiality of its members’ data and requirements to follow EU and US laws."
  • November 23, 2006
    * New UK Law Allows Use of Low Power FM Transmitters for MP3 Players

    Press release, November 23 2006: Ofcom [the regulator for the UK communications industries] today announced that the use of certain low power FM transmitters, which wirelessly connect MP3 players and other personal audio devices to radios and in-car entertainment systems, will be legal for use in the UK from 8 December 2006...in response to consumer demand Ofcom has led negotiations in Europe to develop a harmonised technical approach designed to limit the potential of interference to other wireless devices. The FM transmitters that meet these specifications, and which will be legal to use in the UK, will carry a CE mark indicating approval for sale in the European Union. Their use will be legalised under the Wireless Telegraphy (Exemption) (Amendment) Regulations 2006 which come into effect on 8 December. The regulations set out the technical specifications for FM transmitters."

    November 09, 2006
    * EU: Directive on Prevention of Use of Financial System for the Purpose of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing

    Directive on the prevention of the use of the financial system for the purpose of money laundering and terrorist financing (22 pages, PDF)

  • Press release (PDF): "This measure is intended to combat money-laundering and terrorist financing. It covers many forms of financial transactions including those over 15,000 euros which raise suspicions of financial institutions and for which there is no plausible explanation. There are no data protection provisions but the Directive comes under the 1995 EC Directive on data protection. However, Article 28 which says: "The institutions and persons covered by this Directive and their directors and employees shall not disclose to the customer concerned or to other third persons the fact that information has been transmitted..." is contrary to the rights set out in Articles 10 and 11 of the 1995 Directive on the right of the individual to be informed. Article 27 allows data to be passed to: "a third country which imposes requirements equivalent to those laid down in this Directive, and that they are from the same professional category and are subject to equivalent obligations as regards professional secrecy and personal data protection." - which, theoretically, would prohibit data being passed to the USA." [via Statewatch]
  • October 02, 2006
    * Belgium Privacy Commission Reviews SWIFT Violation of Data Protection Law

    Opinion No. 37 / 2006 of 27 September 2006, O. Ref.: SA2 / A / 2006 / 037- CONCERNING: Opinion on the transfer of personal data by the CSLR SWIFT by virtue of UST (OFAC) subpoenas."During its session of 5th July 2006, the Commission had already made the decision to officially start an investigation into this case on grounds of article 32 § 1 DPL1, regarding the processing of personal data under the responsibility of SWIFT, a cooperative society under Belgian law, with headquarters in Belgium and with limited liability...As far as the communication of personal data to the UST is concerned, the Commission is of the opinion that SWIFT finds itself in a conflict situation between American and European law and that SWIFT at the least committed a number of errors of judgement when dealing with the American subpoenas. It must be considered a serious error of judgement on the part of SWIFT to subject a massive quantity of personal data to surveillance in a secret and systematic manner for years without effective grounds for justification and without independent control in accordance with Belgian and European law..."

    August 16, 2006
    * EU - European Data Protection Supervisor: Annual Report for 2005

    EU - European Data Protection Supervisor: Annual Report for 2005 - Published August 2006 (125 pages, PDF)

    May 30, 2006
    * European Court of Justice Strikes Down US Collection of Passenger Name Records

    BBC: "The European Court of Justice has annulled an EU-US agreement requiring airlines to transfer passenger data to the US authorities."

  • Press release and information from the Court of Justice of the European Communities, May 30, 2006 (3 pages, PDF)

  • Related postings on passenger data collection post 9/11
  • February 22, 2006
    * EU Approves New Data Retention Directive

  • EU press release, 21 February 2006 (21 pages, PDF)
  • See also EU action plan on combatting terrorism, 13 February 2006 (38 pages, PDF)
  • February 15, 2006
    * EU Commission Directive on Data Transfer

    Commission Staff Working Directive, 20/1/06.

    November 23, 2005
    * EU Advocate General Recommends Annulling Agreement to Share Passenger Name Records

    Nº 98/2005: 22 November 2005, Opinion of the Advocate General in cases C-317/04, C-318/04, Parliament/Council, Principles of Community law - press release - Advocate General Léger Proposed Annulment of the Commission and Council Decisions on Transfer to the American Authorities of Personal Information Concerning Air Passengers.

  • Full-text opinion (in French)

  • May 31, 2004, Passenger Data Collection Pact Signed Between EU and US
  • September 09, 2005
    * UK Open Rights Group Begins Work

    UK digital rights group sets up - "The main aims of the Open Rights Group are: to foster a grassroots community of campaigning volunteers; to connect journalists and the press with digital rights experts and activists."

    July 27, 2005
    * New EU Draft Directive on Data Retention

    The EDRI-gram newsletter reported on the release of the new EU Commission explanatory memorandum on data retention, July 20, 2005 (16 pages, PDF).

  • "The European Commission has finally produced its draft directive on data retention. According to the Commission, all fixed and mobile telephony traffic and location data from all private and legal persons should bestored for 1 year. Data about communications 'using solely the internet protocol' should be stored for 6 months."

  • June 27, 2005
    * Italian Lawyers Group Embraces Open Source Software for Document Management

    NewsForge has a detailed and very interesting posting on how a group of Italian attorneys have formed a consortium to facilitate the distribution of, and training programs about how to efficiently use open source applications for a range of document management applications as well as e-filing of court documents.

    April 12, 2005
    * Websites That Offer Consumers Safe Harbor

    Jay Cline reviews a range of popular e-commerce websites that offer consumers a defined list of privacy protections and provides general scores for those that implement portions of the European privacy principles.

    February 22, 2005
    * Smartcard Industry Report Compares Technology With RFID

    RFID Tags and Contactless Smart Card Technology: Comparing and Contrasting Applications and Capabilities

  • See also this chart comparing the features and applications of RFID tags and contactless smart cards.


  • Related resources:
  • From the EU: "On January 19th, the Working Party 29 adopted a Working Document on data protection issues related to RFID technology (Working document 105)...The paper also provides guidance to manufacturers of the technology (RFID tags, readers and applications) as well as RFID standardization bodies on their responsibility towards designing privacy compliant technology in order to enable deployers of the technology to carry out their obligations under the data protection Directive." [Link]
  • December 07, 2004
    * Global Manufacturer To Implement Website Privacy Protection Software

    Consumer product manufacturer Procter & Gamble plans to implement data privacy protection software on its websites (numbering in the hundreds) to meet compliance requirements in Europe, which after testing, will be followed by rollouts in the U.S. and other countries.

    August 31, 2004
    * Open Source Software Under Development for University Financials

    2 Universities Team Up to Create Free, Open-Source Financial Software for Campuses

    June 15, 2004
    * White Paper Profiles Data Protection Issues in U.S. and EU

    A Global Push to Protect Information Online

  • "As indispensible as e-mail and the Internet have become at work, companies face rising threats from the exposure of confidential business data or consumer data over the Internet."
  • May 31, 2004
    * Passenger Data Collection Pact Signed Between EU and US

    See the DHS press release, and the Fact Sheet: US-EU Passenger Name Record Agreement Signed. The transfer of data includes passenger email addresses, phone numbers and credit card information.

    May 18, 2004
    * Privacy Group Issues Report Critical of EU Passenger Data Agreement With US

    From Privacy International: "On May 17, 2004 the European Commission approved an agreement to transfer passenger details to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, an agreement established in the name of, but that has little to do with, the war on terror." Privacy International has published this report, Transferring Privacy and Inadequate Adequacy, documenting what the organization contends entails the release of data to which the U.S. is not statutorily entitled.

  • See also EU agree US PNR deal
  • April 30, 2004
    * Proposed EU Data Retention Laws

    From the French Republic, Ireland, the Kingdom of Sweden and the United Kingdom, date of receipt, 28 April 2004:

  • "Draft Framework Decision on the retention of data processed and stored in connection with the provision of publicly available electronic communications services or data on public communications networks for the purpose of prevention investigation detection and prosecution of crime and criminal offences including terrorism." [link to full-text, pdf]

  • April 21, 2004
    * EU Challenges US on Air Passenger Data

    MEPs take on EU and US over air data deal:

  • "The European Parliament has by 16 votes, 276 in favour, 260 against, agreed to take a privacy rights battle over handovers of air passenger data to US security agencies to the EU courts."

  • April 08, 2004
    * Heightened Focus on Gmail by Privacy Advocates

    From the World Privacy forum, this press release and letter (pdf) on behalf of a coalition of over two dozen privacy and advocacy groups, addressing Google's new webmail service, Gmail, specific to the retention and repurposing of user data for e-commerce and law enforcement applications.

  • Screenshots of Gmail from a beta tester, here and here.
  • April 01, 2004
    * EU Continues to Contest Transfer of Passenger Data

    From Statewatch, April 1:

  • "The European Parliament has passed a Resolution rejecting the draft Directive on "the obligation of carriers to communicate passenger data" and calling for it to be withdrawn. The Directive was put forward by the Spanish government last year and was radically altered by the Justice and Home Affairs Council on 30 March, see: Report and draft Directive.

  • "EU: Full-text of the Resolution adopted by the European Parliament at its plenary session on 31 March 2004 opposing the transfer of passenger data (PNR) to the USA and reserving the right to take the issue to the European Court of Justice: EP Resolution (pdf)."

  • March 10, 2004
    * Compromise Reached on EU Data Protection Laws

  • "Parliament adopted by 439 votes in favour, 39 against and 28 abstentions an own-initiative report on the 1995 Data Protection Directive. The House states firmly that transfers of personal data to third country authorities without consent, such as in the case of the US authorities accessing transatlantic passenger data, seriously infringes EU data protection standards. It considers the progress made over a year of talks with the US on this question to be totally inadequate, and calls for arrangements for data protection in such circumstances to be subject to approval by Parliament in the future." [Link to Report on the First Report on the implementation of the Data Protection Directive (95/46/EC) - Committee on Citizens' Freedoms and Rights, Justice and Home Affairs]

  • Text of the Directive
  • March 09, 2004
    * Report on Proliferation of Video Surveillance in EU

    The EU's Article 29 Working Party on data protection has produced a report on "Video Surveillance". The report sets out guidelines under the 1995 Directive on data protection in relation to surveillance by video cameras in public and work places. [Statewatch News Online] The report states that:

  • "The over-proliferation of image acquisition systems in public and private areas should not result in placing unjustified restrictions on citizens' rights and fundamental freedoms; otherwise, citizens might be actually compelled to undergo disproportionate data collection procedures which would make them massively identifiable in a number of public and private places."
  • December 16, 2003
    * EU Reaches Determination on Passenger Name Record Data Collection

    Quoting from the 16th December 2003 speech by Frits Bolkestein, Member of the European Commission in charge of the Internal Market, Taxation and Customs concering EU Data Protection:

  • "Firstly, clear limits on the amount of data to be transferred with a closed list of 34 elements. Furthermore, the US has undertaken not to require airlines to collect any data where any of these 34 elements would be empty. In practice, most PNRs consist of no more than 10-15 items." The agreement does not cover CAPPS II.

  • See this Department of Homeland Security Fact Sheet: Homeland Security and European Commission Reach PNR Agreement

  • See also my October 9 posting, EU Issues Update on Airline Passenger Data and European Commission/US Customs talk on Passenger Name Record (PNR) transmission, February 2003.
  • December 05, 2003
    * EU Demands Compliance on E-Privacy Directive

    With the expiration of an October 31 deadline for implementing the Directive on Privacy and Electronic Communications, the European Commission indicated that legal action against nine member states may be necessary to ensure their compliance. The directive addresses e-privacy issues that include spam, the use of cookies, and the protection of customer data by ISPs.

    October 31, 2003
    * Compliance With New EU Data Privacy Rules Begins Today

    "As from today EU Member States must comply with the Directive on Privacy and Electronic Communications, which sets EU standards for the protection of privacy and personal data in electronic communications. The Directive includes basic obligations to ensure the security and confidentiality of communications over EU electronic networks, including internet and mobile services. It sets out specific conditions for installing so-called “cookies” on users' personal computers and for using location data generated by mobile phones. Notably, the Directive also introduces a 'ban on spam' throughout the EU." [Link]

  • Background information on the new rules is available here

  • Background information on the specific Commission plans on spam is available here
  • October 13, 2003
    * EU v. U.S. Data Protection Policies

    From the Wall Street Journal, October 10:

  • "While the U.S. has opposed comprehensive regulations to protect citizens' privacy, Europe has plowed ahead with the world's toughest set of rules governing how companies and governments may deal with personal data, such as one's age, marital status, buying patterns -- even the information on a standard business card.
  • October 09, 2003
    * EU Issues Update on Airline Passenger Data

    Via Statewatch, this statement by the European Parliament on the need for strict restrictions on the collection, dissemination and maintenance of non-U.S. citizen personal data collected by airlines for transatlantic flights.

  • List of 43 data elements on airline passengers requested by the United States from transatlantic air carriers.
  • September 18, 2003
    * EU Airline Passenger Data Resolution

    25th International Conference of Data Protection & Privacy Commissioners Sydney, 12 September 2003 - Resolution concerning the Transfer of Passengers’ Data.

  • See also EU challenges U.S. passenger data plan

  • September 10, 2003
    * New Report on Implementing EU Copyright Directive

    From the independent group, the Foundation for Information Policy Research, this new guide, published September 8, Implementing the EU Copyright Directive, (128 pages, pdf). See this link for a table of contents to download specific sections in html, which include the following:

  • Background; Problems in the United States; Immediate public policy objectives; Wider public policy objectives; The Copyright Directive; Options for implementation; Summary of implementations, and country reports.

  • See also Copyright directive 'could be Europe's DMCA'
  • September 05, 2003
    * Airline Passenger Data Conflict Between US and EU

    From Statewatch.com:

  • "European Commission tells USA that demands for access to data on airline passengers breaches EU Data Protection Directive - correspondence reveals that USA is also asking for Advance Passenger Information to vet those flying."
  • August 13, 2003
    * Opposition to EU IP Directive

    From European Digital Rights, an association of privacy and civil rights organizations in Europe:

  • CODE Letter urging rejection of Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on measures and procedures to ensure the enforcement of intellectual property rights.
  • IP Justice White Paper on Proposed European Union IP Enforcement Directive

  • June 19, 2003
    * EU Objections to US Collection of Airline Passenger Data

    Via StateWatch: The EU's Article 29 Data Protection Working Party has issued a strong report on access by the USA to personal data on passengers flying from the EU to the USA.

    June 17, 2003
    * Libraries, Copyright and Licensing

    Copyright and licensing for digital preservation. "Libraries cannot preserve digital material they do not own. Adrienne Muir describes a new project to identify copyright and licensing issues that currently hinder digital preservation and looks at whether new legislation (UK) will help."

    June 13, 2003
    * UK Guidelines on Employee Web Monitoring

    From Internet Magazine, news of the publication, by the UK Information Commissioner, responsible for data protection & freedom of information, of the third part of the Employment Practices Data Protection Code - Monitoring at Work, the Do's & Don't for workplace monitoring. Links to these documents, and to the other parts of the guide, are available here. Also see the Trades Union Congress website, called workSMART, that provides resources on workplace monitoring and internet policies.

    May 29, 2003
    * Proposed New EU Constitution

    From UPI: "A proposed European constitution...calls for an elected president of Europe and a binding bill of rights, but at Britain's insistence, it drops the notion of creating a federal "United States of Europe." An edited version of the draft is available here.

    The full-text of the six documents (in pdf) are as follows:

  • Preamble

  • Draft Constitution, Volume I - Revised text of Part One

  • Draft Constitution, Volume II - Draft text of Parts Two, Three and Four

  • Draft text of Part II with comments

  • Draft sections of Part Three with comments

  • Draft text of Part IV with comments


  • May 06, 2003
    * Advocacy Group Seeks to Block Transfer of European Passenger Data

    European Digital Rights (EDRi), a non-profit coalition of privacy/advocacy groups based in Brussels, launched a campaign against the transfer of European travellers' Passenger Name Records (PNR) to U.S. Customs. See the following related documents:

  • EDRi campaign press release.

  • Full text of Article 29 Data Protection Working Party: Opinion 6/2002 on transmission of Passenger Manifest Information and other data from Airlines to the United States, adopted 24 October 2002, doc no: 11647/02/EN, WP 66 (pdf).

  • European Commission/US Customs talks on PNR transmission, brussels, 17/18 February 2003, joint statement.

  • May 05, 2003
    * EU Websites Lacking Privacy Protections

    Contrary to the EU Data Protection Directive (pdf), a recent study determined that approximately 44% of European websites surveyed lack required privacy protection policies. The results indicated the greatest complaince was evidenced by UK sites and the worst by French sites.

    April 14, 2003
    * New German Copyright Law Opposed by Publishers

    According to the Chronicle of Higher Education, the recently amended German Copyright Law (pdf - in German) now exempts universities from fees associated with providing students and scholars with copyrighted materials in a digital environment. For additional information, please see this April 10 posting from amiga-news.de, New Copyright as Good as Succeeded, which provides some additional background about the law, as well as a link to an article from the German IT news publication, Golem (no translation available), and one from Der Spiegel (also in German). Anyone who can provide translation assistance for the law and these articles for beSpacific readers, please contact me. My thanks in advance. See also this brief article, Germany trying to copy DMCA (in English).

    See also my recent postings on U.S. copyright and distance learning issues here and here.

    April 07, 2003
    * New UK Legal Info Blog

    The Information Law Weblog was launched March 28, is by librarian/researcher/author Paul Pedley, and focuses on copyright, data protection and freedom of information issues in the UK. Well worth a visit. (Thanks to DC for the link.)

    March 28, 2003
    * CAPPS II and EU Passenger Data Collection

    EPIC continues to expand its challenge to the CAPPS II System by documenting objections to the progam that impact European airline passengers, in a statement (pdf) submitted to the EU Committee on Citizens' Freedoms and Rights, Justice and Home Affairs for a hearing held March 25.

    See also this announcement today: Spain proposes data on all airline passengers to be sent to law enforcement agencies and for extra checks on all foreign nationals entering the EU.

    March 11, 2003
    * EU Response to U.S. Demand for Passenger Data

    From StateWatch, this report (PDF) from the European Parliament's Committee on Citizens' Freedoms expressing strong concerns about the collection and use of EU passenger data by the INS and TSA.

    See also How US Customs bounced the European Commission into a quick decision.

    March 05, 2003
    * EU Approves Hacker Penalties

    EU Ministers agreed to establish a new criminal offense, "illegally accessing an information system," which would include incarceration for "serious cases." The text of this new policy is buried on page 19 of this 27 page document (PDF), under the heading "Attacks Against Information Systems." See also this related article in today's New York Times, Europe Hacker Laws Could Make Protest a Crime.

    See also a recent press release: European Commission proposes creation of Network Security Agency to boost Cyber Security in Europe.

    January 31, 2003
    * New EU Data Protection Proposal

    The European Commission on Data Protection Working Party issued a new directive on January 29 addressing the protection of personal online data and the enforcement of IP rights. The Working Document, On-line Authentication Services, is here.

    January 23, 2003
    * EU Coalition Opposes Data Retention

    This recommendation to the Council of the European Union from 38 Members of Parliament from 7 political groups, conveys the groups opposition to the EU Data Directive which permits data mining, document retention and electronic surveillance programs involving citizens. The group states that these actions are "a violation of art. 8 of the European Court of Human Rights."

    October 01, 2002
    * U.S. Corporations Seek Relaxation of EU Privacy Rules

    ZDNet UK is reporting that a coalition of prominent U.S. high tech companies, calling themselves the Global Privacy Alliance (no web site available) wants the EU to relax its data protection laws to stimulate international e-commerce through the transfer of personal data collected on customers.

    September 16, 2002
    * EU Data Protection Commissioners Oppose Data Retention

    StateWatch.org reports that the Commissioners' stated: "Where traffic data are to be retained in specific cases, there must therefore be a demonstrable need, the period of retention must be as short as possible and the practice must be clearly regulated by law, in a way that provides sufficient safeguards against unlawful access and any other abuse. Systematic retention of all kinds of traffic data for a period of one year or more would be clearly disproportionate and therefore unacceptable in any case."